by CWSmith » Mon May 19, 2014 5:38 pm
Now that I've had time to gather my thoughts (and see the film a second time lol), let's see if I can give this movie the review it deserves.
-First and foremost I stand by my original thought that this is a fantastic movie that, like others have said, plays incredibly well on multiple viewings. I believe on my first viewing I found myself counting Godzilla's time on screen like an accountant. On my second viewing, I let myself go and I enjoyed the movie infinitely more. The movie flows very well and I think Godzilla has plenty of screen time. There's no question who the real star of the movie is.
-When it comes to the criticisms of the human element, I find them for the most part unfounded. Cranston is really great and owns the first 30 minutes. While I understand disappointment that he dies so early on, I really don't understand the complaints with Aaron Taylor-Johnson. He's playing things stoic yes, but that seems to be in character for a military man to me. I don't think people criticizing him as wooden know what true bad acting really is. Go rewatch Hayden in the Star Wars prequels and come back to me. I thought Watanabe and Strathairn were both excellent and served their respective purposes. The parallels between father and son with Joe and Ford Brody was compelling to me with Ford struggling to do what his father couldn't do: save his family.
-The monsters were all pretty much flawless. I love the MUTOs and I think they're a very worthy addition to the canon. The Big G himself was amazing of course, just oozing machismo and bad assitude. Four times during BOTH my viewings he made the crowd burst into spontaneous cheering: his first appearance in Hawaii, the debut of the atomic fire, the tail whip that killed the male MUTO, and of course, the kiss of death.
-Overall I think I'm sticking with a 9/10. One of the best action movies I've seen in years with genuinely great pacing that makes you crave the huge fight at the end. I really love the contrast between this film and most modern action movies that are constant action upon action upon action until the audience is unfeeling to it. Here, EVERY action set piece is properly built up and has proper meaning. Its very much an old school Hollywood film.
-As far as where this ranks in Godzilla filmdom, I'd place it roughly 4th or 5th. I can't put it up there with G54 or MothravG, but damn is it close.