No, no, no no, they got it wrong! For one thing, everyone was speaking English! They should have dubbed this in Japanese so that we could have subtitles!
Actually, thumbs way up on this one. It is not perfect, but then again, none of the other Godzilla movies are either (yes including the first one, if I am allowed to sound blasphemous).
When this project first came to fruition, I was fearful that we would get another retread or clichéd “Godzilla is an unstoppable force of nature wrecking havoc on humankind”. I think we’ve had enough of those. Instead, this movie felt like a 1960s Showa feature, where Godzilla
is the unintentional good guy.
Others have talked about the characters, and probably better than I could ever do, so I won’t dwell on that aspect. The only disappointing (and curious) thing was having an esteem actress like Juliette Binoche not really much in it, other than a good death scene.
The Muto creatures were great. A fat Godzilla maybe, but he was quite serviceable. Special effects were top-notch!
As for comparing it with others, I still think it is actually quite silly doing that since this is a whole different universe we are talking about. I did not much care for Richard Pusateri’s review because in his head, he was already comparing it to the first movie, and I’m assuming that is probably his favorite or what he thought was the best made of Toho’s output. Essentially, that is already putting one strike against this film. We all have our list of favorite G-films and psychologically, it is pretty much set in stone. Sure there is always some fluctuation, but usually not on a massive scale. “Destroy All Monsters” AIP version is and will always be my all time favorite G-film. And because this was not like DAM, I am not (and should not) going to hold that against it. The Toho Godzilla films are their own entity. The better comparison is pitting this with the other American Godzilla picture. And definitely, this movie was everything GINO was not and what GINO wanted to be – a well executed monster film.