by jellydonut25 » Thu Jan 26, 2017 3:49 pm
Silence - For a twenty-year passion project, Silence seems at times slapped together, and not entirely thought-through. Scorsese only flirts with asking and musing on some interesting questions, but ultimately shies away from getting as philosophical/theological as this subject matter essentially demands, instead focusing on 90 minutes of "Will he/won't he" with torture sprinkled in. It's unusual for someone with Scorsese's prowess to be so light-handed in his examination of something so heavy, but here is Silence, which starts with a rather gripping first hour but over the next 90 minutes loses all of that steam and ends on a final 15 minutes that seems unconscionably lazy. This movie only made me curious to seek out the novel and its prior adaptations to see if there's something inherently flawed in the source material of if, in the strive to just get this movie made, Scorsese somehow lost sight of WHY he wanted to make it in the first place...or perhaps, to give an individual of Scorsese's talent more credit, became TOO focused on why he wanted to get it made, and just barrelled his movie forward toward the conclusion he wanted rather than examine how and why it should have earned that ending.
^Silence I was LEGITIMATELY interested in, due to Scorsese, but then I checked out a bunch of movies that were getting Oscar buzz (like, before the nominees were announced just the other day) and had that "hot critic buzz" from people who make their year-end lists and populate them with more artsy fair...because every few years I try to cast my net as WIDE AS POSSIBLE and see AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE to see how my tastes may have shifted. For example, I'm sure like 5-10 years ago, I probably wouldn't have sought out Swiss Army Man, or liked it much, but it was my favorite movie of the year. La La Land is another I probably would have HATED like 10 years ago and it was my 4th favorite movie of the year...so in the spirit of seeing if I've shifted my tastes around again:
Moonlight - Disjointed and lacking a strong narrative thrust (are those the same thing?), Moonlight is a "good" movie that doesn't strike much of a cord and will be forgotten before too long (by me, at least). Too often in this movie (almost literally every time it happens) just when things get really interesting, and reach a potential turning point, it smash cuts and ends that plot thread. Characters are given a spotlight for 30 minutes or so and then never seen or heard from again, one of the MAIN characters at the beginning of the film even dies off-screen. The emotional payoff at the end doesn't feel earned and the whole thing just feels like a character study of a miserable life and though it's "good" it's pretty unpleasant and not something I'd ever want to revisit.
Fences - Good performances, but I did not GIVE A F***.
Christine - Rebecca Hall gives a good performance, but Kate Plays Christine is the far more interesting movie about Christine Chubbuck.
Jackie - Another "good performance, didn't care at all" movie.
Manchester by the Sea - While it's good, this is probably the straw that broke the camel's back, so to speak. I'll almost always ultimately seek out the Best Picture nominees of a given year, just to have my say/opinion on an event as big as the Oscars, but I'm more or less done (at least for a few years) with seeking out EVERYTHING that has Oscar-buzz. I know I would have wound up watching Manchester by the Sea as a BP nom, but I would have saved myself some of the other films I've watched recently that are this film's lesser-kin.
This is yet ANOTHER film with good performances, and well-fleshed-out characters...but no story. I understand not literally "everyone" can, but: anyone can write good characters, and anyone can write a good/complex story, but when there are so many films out there that can do BOTH to at least competent extents, I no longer have much interest in movies that can only do ONE (and for my tastes, if it's only going to do one, give me a good story).
So, while this movie is good at what it does, it left me kind of cold and I'm sure I'll probably forget about it before too long.
Now, I've seen a LOT of movies this year (more movies than I've listed here, by a pretty decent amount), and I feel like I'll reign it in a little more for 2017 and only seek out stuff that seems interesting to me rather than just kinda EVERYTHING that gets high praise.