by Rodanex » Sun May 29, 2016 11:52 am
I really enjoyed the last two X-Men films, but this one was kind of a mess.
There are some pretty big narrative flaws (the movie takes an abrupt left turn halfway through, whisking the characters off to a subplot that has literally nothing to do with the rest of the story), and there's a lot of little plot holes that really start to add up. Nightcrawler conveniently forgets how his powers work, allowing some humans to trap him inside an electrified cage. Mystique is somehow able to remain in J. Law-mode even though she's in a room that supposedly nullifies mutant powers. Speaking of Mystique, remember how she disguised herself as Stryker in the last movie so she could prevent Logan from being taken by the government? Yeah, they don't follow up on that at all. In fact, they completely contradict that ending. I don't really understand why Apocalypse wakes up when he does, they just show some guys chanting and praying in this underground cave, and then he awakens. I'm not clear on why this cult wasn't able to awaken Apocalypse 1000 years ago, or 100 years ago, or a few days ago. Also, why the hell is Moira McTaggert investigating this cult to begin with? I won't spoil the ending, but it's a giant deus ex machina.
All logic flaws aside, I think the main problem with this film is that it fails to really be about anything more than a bunch of superheroes punching a villain to death. X-Men First Class has the subtext of learning to be proud of who you are, Days of Future Past has Xavier learning that he can't control Raven and he has to let her make her own decisions. I feel like the best comic book movies find ways to have depth beyond superbeings fighting, and this one....doesn't.
A lot of people are making a huge deal out of the Quicksilver scene, and I really don't get the hype. It was neat in the last movie, here it just seems repetitive. Are we going to have to do this every single time Quicksilver appears in an X-Men movie? Also, it happens right after something that should be sad and tragic and very abruptly turns it into essentially a comic-relief bit.
Almost as a counterpoint to Civil War's expert handling of many different characters, this film fails miserably. Psylocke and Angel come across as one-dimensional thugs. (Also, wouldn't Angel be an infant in 1983? He was in his late teens/early 20s in The Last Stand) Storm is probably the best developed of the Horsemen. Magneto is just kind of there, going through familiar character beats again...Fassbender is a great actor, but he really doesn't have much to work with here.
It's not all bad...I though the casting was great. Just about all of the new actors do a great job (with the exception of Olivia Munn and Ben Hardy, mostly because they have nothing to work with). I didn't really mind the look of Apocalypse, even if he looks a bit like a super sentai villain. I actually think the beginning of the movie is pretty good, it was neat seeing some characterization and back story for Scott Summers, even if it's a little too reminiscent of Wolverine coming to the X-Mansion for the first time.
I don't mean to sound like I'm nitpicking...I really wanted to like this movie, but I just couldn't do it. It's not the worst thing ever, but it's just kind of stupid entertainment without anything deeper beneath it.