by jellydonut25 » Mon Oct 21, 2013 12:11 pm
^No, the point of the Phantom of the Opera is not singing. The Schumacher film is basically a film version of the Broadway musical...in which case, singing makes sense and advances the story. Many of the songs are ABOUT the characters, their motivations, their actions, the story, etc
The musical numbers in the 1943 film are show-stoppers in the literal, awful sense. They bring the film to a screeching halt, with absolutely ZERO importance with regards to the storyline. They are silly songs meant to showcase nothing but the scenery, and there's no advancement of the drama, tension, or story whatsoever. I'd rather watch the Schumacher film, because at least the songs are good. The 1943 film features terrible comedy, a ruination of the Phantom character, asinine motivations for the characters, a Scooby-Doo-quality mystery, and a Son of Kong-like blink-and-you-miss-it finale. I loathe it, and find it unfortunate that an actor of Claude Rains's talents was so spectacularly WASTED on it.
As for Nosferatu, the 1925 Phantom of the Opera is better than Nosferatu all day long. ALL. DAY. LONG. Forever and always.
Nosferatu is an uneven film. Some of the scenery and imagery is striking and haunting and Count Orlock remains one of the top scariest vampires in cinema history, but there's not much else to the movie, and even at 84 minutes, it DRAGS considerably at times. Much like the Browning's Dracula, it features a good performance from the vampire and the Renfield character, but lacks in characterization and supporting cast, even by the standards of the time. It's an important piece of film history, but it's a bit inaccessible as a movie.
Phantom of the Opera, on the other hand, has all the striking imagery and scenery of Nosferatu, and a spectacular makeup job on the monster creating one of the most terrifying creatures in film history...AND it's a good movie as well. The pacing is tighter, the performances are better, the story is more fully developed, and the technicolor sequence is MIND-BLOWING.