by jellydonut25 » Tue Dec 04, 2012 11:43 am
(I apologize in advance for the long read, but a lot of these thoughts are kinda new for me...or at least my first time stating them)
The Dark Knight - While watching this, I was struck (and probably not for the first time, but who knows for sure? I don't feel like looking back through dozens/hundreds of posts to figure out if I've brought this up before) by the similarities between Nolan's Batman Trilogy and the original Star Wars Trilogy.
In that case, The Dark Knight is The Empire Strikes Back of its series, and for me that metaphor works to near-perfection. The production is slicker, more refined, and a little more cohesive, the "alliance" is more fractured, dysfunctional and upended, the bad guys have rallied their strength, tightened their forces, and gone on an all-out attack, and at the end, make no mistake, the bad guys win. Sure, the Dent Act ends up coming out of it and all that stuff, but in the REAL battle here, The Joker wins. He lives to fight another day (unfortunately never realized on film), he pushes Batman to his limits and perhaps beyond, he basically destroys Gordon's faith and the MCU, and he turns Harvey from hero to villain. He forces Batman to take the blame for five deaths!
Not only is this "Empire" in terms of production value, tone, and execution, but it also has that more open-ended feeling that lets you know there's going to be another one.
And to top that all off, it is admittedly my favorite of the series. I know that's the "popular" opinion, and it's often considered less "cool" or less "intelligent" to just "go along" with the "masses" but I don't care. Between Ledger's portrayal of the Joker, the Harvey Dent arc (which I would NEVER have thought could have been done justice in one film, but was totally proven wrong), and Bale/Caine/Freeman/Oldman all turning in fine performances once again, I can't help but love this movie.
A little too dark, a little too gritty? MAYBE...but not totally joyless, either...in the midst of epic feelings and serious drama, people lose sight of all the little moments of humor (mostly between Bale and Caine):
-"Were you mauled by a tiger?" 'It was a dog' (looks incredulous) 'It was a BIG dog'
-"I suppose they'll lock me up with you, as your accomplice" 'Accomplice? I'm gonna tell them the whole thing was your idea.'
and there's a whole bunch of other little, subtle, light-hearted moments (or moments that make light of some of the darker things) that add just enough levity to keep the movie from feeling too oppressively dark.
I haven't seen TDKR since the theater, but I kind of feel like this is an aspect that the third film lost sight of a little bit...
...which actually plays FURTHER into my Star Wars analogy...RotJ loses sight just a little bit of the interplay between the main characters and the levity of their interactions in favor of something more serious, which has the overall effect of making the moments that are perhaps unintentionally funny seem out of place and goofy instead of just part of the 'fun factor'. Much like TDKR (again keeping in mind I've only seen the damn movie once).
So, in conclusion, The Dark Knight is a fantastic film, and it is my personal opinion that 90% of the people who don't like it merely feel that way because they think it's "cool" to be contrary, because if you actually look at the movie and leave all preconceived notions aside, it might be a touch overlong, a touch over serious, and a touch overacted, but it's really nothing short of a masterpiece.