Godzilla vs. Gigan (Dubbed in English, Brand New Starmaker VHS)
Recently I won an ebay auction for the old Starmaker videotape set of Godzilla films.
Since the only movie I owned in the set was
Godzilla 1985, and since I hadn't seen the rest in ages I figured the set would be a cheap, fun time killer until I got around to buying the Japanese versions of the films.
My girlfriend and I watch the movies together (she's an anime fan and I got her into the Heisei series originally, but exposure to the other monsters in the X-Box Godzilla game made her more interested in seeing the Showa series as well) and her favorite monster is Anguirus while mine is Gigan, so I think you can guess which movie we watched first.
First, about the tape: This version is God-awful. While the dubbing is actually pretty good (surprisingly so), the overall quality is horrifying. The pan and scan makes it next to impossible to tell just what the heck is going on in many of the fight scenes, and the picture varies wildly between "meh" and "totally craptastic" as the film goes back and forth between original material and stock footage.
This film would have easily been a whole lot easier to watch with a better looking letterboxed picture, that's for freakin' sure.
Anyway, I found the movie to be good fun. Goofy, likable characters help make up for the unimaginitive alien invaders that never really manage to be anything more then two dimensional mustache twirling bad guys. You've got to love our ragtag group of heroes that consists of members such as the manga artist, the fat-and-constantly-eating-hippie, and the kung fu girlfriend from Hell.
Can't say I much care for the Godzilla suit though (or the return of that
Son of Godzilla bloated cookie monster suit for the water scenes..... no offense to the board member Musukogoji - to each their own

). Besides the fact that the suit has a really.... awkward looking neck, it is visibly fraying apart during the film.
Likewise Ghidorah is looking kind of.... tranquilized. It's interesting to see how much better the effects crew of the movies in the stock footage were at utilizing Ghidorah then the effects crew of
this film. I won't even get started on the stupid little toy Ghidorah they used for the flying scenes.
Anguirus just looked kind of "meh." I don't know if he also had a different "water" suit or not, but he tended to look better on the land scenes.
Gigan, however, was awesome, and everything I remembered him to be. A very cool design, and a very well done suit. Deserving of a much, much better movie.
As far as the fight itself, well what I could see of it was very cool. The Godzilla and Gigan one-on-one match up was just brutal. Lots of grappling punctuated by the occassional bright red spray of blood or blue spray of flame.
I also loved the Godzilla/Anguirus team up on King Ghidorah. Classic.
Overall,
Godzilla vs. Gigan could be a fun little flick. Three things hold it back more then anything: The quality of the tape, the continuous and obvious use of stock footage, and the horrifying Ghidorah flying model. More then anything else it is these things that distracted me from the otherwise good time I was having with the picture.
So overall score (of this particular version of the film): ** out of *****