by jellydonut25 » Wed Oct 28, 2015 12:29 pm
I'm surprised to see as much positive feedback on Homerzilla as I have.
I thought it was bad. The Simpsons has done "poor dubbing" jokes already in the past (the episode Marge in Chains, where everyone gets the Osaka flu from juicers ordered from Japan), and FINALLY doing a Godzilla segment, only to have the whole crux of the segment be a joke from 1998 seems....DUMB. It seems a lot of reviewers are interpreting the latter half of the segment as a rip on the 2014 film, but I think the adjusted posture of Homerzilla, the reference to Zilla, the references to it bombing are all obviously 1998 jokes, which of course means they waited 26 years to do a Godzilla segment, and when they finally did, chose to do a joke from 17 years ago, AND picked the lowest-hanging, boringest fruit of all. Nancy Cartwright, Hank Azaria, and Harry Shearer were all in GINO, and they made NO use of that. Not to mention, other than Lisa and Grampa, they made NO use of it being SIMPSONS characters. The great thing about something like King Homer was that Homer falls in love with Marge, and Lenny is still kinda buddies with Homer and Burns and Smithers have their usual repartee. Homerzilla has NONE of that. It isn't a SIMPSONS Godzilla parody, it's just a crappy Godzilla parody, with bad-dub jokes, and "the movies are cheap" jokes. Yay? Some have complained about the "racist" accents they did, but I thought that was more a function of how a lot of people were honestly first introduced to these movies, and being true to that style of dubbing...my complaints are that there weren't many jokes, the few they did give us were from 17 years ago, and the whole thing had a palpable air of laziness to it. The Simpsons writers claim they look forward to Treehouse the most every year because it gives them the most freedom and is fun, albeit challenging for them to come up with ideas. If this is them when they feel they're pushing themselves, then color me glad I don't watch the show anymore because I'd HATE to see them when they feel like they're phoning it in a little bit.
Flipside, I actually thought the Sideshow Bob segment was mostly enjoyable. After the opening, which I didn't ADORE, but found a neat "Simpsons in Ren & Stimpy" thing, and the Sideshow Bob segment, I was riding pretty high and ready to just fall in love with the Treehouse of Horror once again. Then Homerzilla showed up and I was reminded of just how far the show has fallen.