by lhb412 » Sat Dec 22, 2012 2:59 am
Watched the 1999 TV movie version of A Christmas Carol, starring Patrick Stewart. Despite some top-quality actors it's a largely dull and lifeless execution. Sure, the story (in Dickens' original and most adaptation) addresses serious social issues, but it's a mix of drama, melodrama, ghost story elements, and is very funny... but this version tries to strip it down into the straightest drama possible, and I think is weaker because of it. It's joyless, and therefore missing the point.