by Benjamin Haines » Sun Oct 22, 2023 4:22 pm
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011) - After all these years, I've finally seen this fourth entry in Disney's Pirates of the Caribbean film series. I saw the first three back when they were new, during my high school years, but I was already well into college by the time this fourth movie came out and my lady and I just never got around to it back then. I know we've both watched the first movie multiple times over the years but I hadn't seen the second or third films since around 2008 and I don't think she had either, so we recently rewatched all of them before this one. The Curse of the Black Pearl is still as great as ever, a brilliantly written and directed adventure film with a lightning-in-a-bottle cast who bring their characters to life with gusto. It works especially well because the premise is such a straightforward historical drama with one supernatural element at its core. The cursed Aztec gold turned Captain Barbossa and his crew of pirates into undead ghouls whose true forms are only visible in moonlight, and that stands out as weird and unusual against the 18th-century Caribbean landscape that the movie depicts. It's the sequels that turn the series into full-fledged fantasy by introducing all sorts of different supernatural elements, from the giant Kraken sea monster to the goddess Calypso, from the otherworldly realm of Davy Jones' Locker to the underwater-swimming ship the Flying Dutchman. My opinions of Dead Man's Chest and At World's End really haven't changed. They're over-the-top and excessive as all hell, never achieving the earnest spirit or organic storytelling of the original, but they're still fun and captivating swashbucklers. With production budgets of $225m and $300m respectively, the second and third Pirates each broke the record for the most expensive movie ever produced when they were released and every cent is up there on the screen to appreciate. Dead Man's Chest suffers the most from scattershot plotting and a lack of natural character motivations, as it's forced to continue from the first story's conclusion while teeing up all of the characters for the cliffhanger ending leading to the third film. It's great to see this cast again but the movie struggles to find a role for Elizabeth Swann, while Jack Sparrow goes from the purpose-driven and scene-stealing scallywag of the first film to a rather unsympathetic coward whose only goal seems to be to run away at everyone else's expense. At World's End continues pulling plot elements out of thin air but it benefits from all of the previous film's table-setting with a much more urgent and substantial story driving all of the action. It takes everything to new heights of insanity while letting the characters come into their own.
On Stranger Tides is a peculiar movie. It's entertaining, don't get me wrong, and I'm certainly glad that I finally checked it out. It has some good qualities, some bad qualities, and some genuinely confounding qualities. It takes a reasonable approach to continuing the series with a fourth film: the stories of Elizabeth Swann and Will Turner have been told, so Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom don't return, and the focus shifts squarely to Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow as the lead character, with Geoffrey Rush as Barbossa and Kevin McNally as Gibbs returning in supporting roles, and the rest of the cast being almost all fresh faces.
The supernatural element at the center of the story is the fabled Fountain of Youth which everyone is after: the British, the Spanish, Captain Blackbeard (Ian McShane) and his daughter Angelica (Penelope Cruz), and of course Jack. Barbossa has lost the Black Pearl and one of his legs, gained a peg leg and given up the pirate life to work as a captain for the British.
The extended action sequence that opens the movie culminates with another cameo appearance by Jack's father, with Keith Richards briefly reprising his role from the third film. Sure, it's fun to see him again but it instantly makes his previous cameo near the end of the third film seem less special in retrospect, and his brief role here is primarily to dump a lot of plot exposition on Jack and send him on his way. Jack reconnects with his ex-lover Angelica and she brings him aboard the Queen Anne's Revenge to help Blackbeard find the Fountain of Youth.
All of that would have been a compelling enough premise for this story, and yet the movie proceeds to toss in so many additional supernatural elements left and right. According to a prophecy, in order for water from the Fountain of Youth to work, it requires two silver chalices located on Ponce de Leon's ship, as well as a mermaid's tear. Two people must drink the Fountain's water from the silver chalices, one of which must also contain the mermaid's tear, so that the person who drinks the water with the tear will gain all of the remaining years of life from the other person. The inclusion of mermaids makes for the best action sequence midway through the film, with the mermaids depicted as vicious predators of the sea, luring victims with their song and then leaping out of the water in mass numbers. Blackbeard's capture of a mermaid leads to a minor romantic subplot between her and a captured missionary among Blackbeard's crew, which comes across as a pale imitation of the romance between Will and Elizabeth from the first three flicks.
Still, even with all of those gratuitous story elements, none of that sticks out like a sore thumb or drags the movie down. By far the most egregious things in this movie are the supernatural elements involving Blackbeard. Apparently having Blackbeard himself as the antagonist in a Pirates of the Caribbean film just wasn't enough, because this take on Blackbeard has several zombies as the top members of his ship's crew. Blackbeard also uses a voodoo doll to torment Jack. Blackbeard also has a magical sword that enables him to project his will to physically move ships and parts of ships, which he demonstrates when he quells a mutiny by causing the ship's ropes to tie up his treacherous crew. Blackbeard's ship is also equipped with giant flamethrower cannons. Blackbeard has also taken every ship he has sunk and somehow shrunken them down into tiny ships which he keeps in glass bottles, including the Black Pearl, complete with miniaturized ocean waves and cloudy skies inside the bottles too. It's all just pointless nonsense that left me wondering why they did it.
The highlight of this film is Barbossa's subplot, from seeing him command a British ship with wanton disregard for the crew to the buddy-movie scenes he eventually shares with Jack as their paths merge in search of the Fountain of Youth. The ending of the flick is over-the-top nutty across the board but it works in the context of this crazy story with satisfying resolutions for all of the main characters.
It's not a bad movie overall, although I would rank it in fourth place compared to its predecessors just by default. It's about as narratively forced as the second flick but the action sequences and visual style are sorely missing Gore Verbinski's polished direction. I do admire how On Stranger Tides is a less action-packed movie than the prior sequels, with a third act finale that's more intimate than bombastic. That's why I'm surprised that this flick apparently broke At World's End's record as the most expensive film ever produced at the time it was released, because it doesn't show it onscreen.