by Moonlight SY-3 » Fri Aug 19, 2005 8:36 pm
Interesting stuff. Looking forward to the action when it comes.
In general, the writing is good, but at times unclear and unfocused. I found myself reading passages two or three times in an attempt to follow what you were trying to say. Not big problems, but definitely a hindrance to the smooth flow of the story.
Some nit-picky technical things:
I don't know how familiar you are with Japanese surnames, or how you chose the surnames for your characters, but several stood out as a bit unusual: Hakauyate, Udea, and to a lesser extent, Arigama.
I have never heard of these as Japanese surnames, and a quick search revealed no examples. Of course, there are always exceptions, but since you appear to be striving for a very realistic portrayal of Japan and all things Japanese in your story, I thought you'd like an opinion on this point.
Also, at one point you list Yokosuka and the Inland Sea in a slightly confusing passage that might lead some to think that Yokosuka was near the Inland Sea, which it is not (by about 500 kilometers).
Anyway, it's obvious that you are putting a lot of work into your story, and I hope you are encouraged to continue to do so.
And thank you so much for not including a "beautiful Japanese scientist/Kaijuologist/reporter/whatever" in your story. That has to be the most cliched device in Kaiju fan fiction.
(My apologies if one was coming later!)
Last edited by
Moonlight SY-3 on Wed Aug 24, 2005 9:15 am, edited 1 time in total.
~Brian