by lhb412 » Sun Mar 16, 2025 7:02 pm
Well, was a day late in actually digging in because I spent most of yesterday hunkering down for severe weather that never showed! Anyway...
Unsurprisingly, this is a substantial upgrade over what we had before. Even if you don't have 4K and just watch the Blu-ray (the 4k edition has both discs) you're talking far greater detail, better color, and if any artificial de-noising has been done (Japan is a bit notorious for this) it's been lightly applied, retaining a filmic look with visible grain. It hasn't been scrubbed into looking artificially shiny and new if that's what worries you. It still looks 1989, you know? I had fun spotting the tiny details that were invisible before; specks of dirt on the lens, beads of water, dripping monster slime...
Haven't gone through all the extras yet. Only listened to a bit of Samm's commentary; sounds good, she's a pro. Haven't read the essay. As for the extras licensed from Toho we have two featurettes that were included in the previous North American release, and two new-to-us inclusions. The first is a 7 minute reel of unused effects shots in HD (but unrestored) that only overlaps a bit with the deleted shots featured in the behind the scenes doc. The second is a complete collection of teasers, trailers, and TV spots that really suprised me (watch 'em to find out why!).
Funny thing, even though the hour-ling making of special and the concept design featurette are standard def, shot-on-video affairs even they are substantially better looking than their Echo Bridge presentations! They were both blurrier and noisier on the old disc.
I hope this is the standard for further Criterion releases. Presentation of the film, mix of new and licensed extras, great original art, and a suprise in the packaging that really made me smile when I saw it. If only every entry in the series gets this much respect!