by Hamster » Wed Jan 20, 2010 1:29 am
Okay, I have now seen Ultraman: The Next, Ultraman Mebius and the Ultra Brothers, and Super 8 Ultra Brothers. Here's how I rank them.
1. Ultraman: The Next -- While I Understand a lot of the criticism brought to the movie, I still think it's the best Ultraman movie that I've seen so far. Plus, I retain that this film is the best to introduce someone to the fandom if you're going to bother doing it with a movie and not the first episode of the original Ultraman (which I just used to introduce two people, and they loved it). I like the new style that they used around the story, and it took the Ultraman story from an angle that appeals to a broad scale of audience. If I was to produce an Ultraman in America, I'd use many of the story elements from this film.
2. Ultraman Mebius and the Ultra Brothers -- Shallow plot. So shallow it's almost unbearable. But, overall, it's grand fun. The bad guys are fun, the battles are awesome, and there's a lot of great homage to the original series of Ultraman, Ultraseven, Ace, and Jack (from what I can tell). There are many points where you are genuinely concerned for the heroes with the situations they keep getting into. And Yapool was a great bad guy for the film as well, his personality was fun and added to the film. If it had tried to go a little deeper with the plot, this film could've been great.
3. Super 8 Ultra Brothers -- The first half of this film is incredible. The monster battles are amazing, the setup is awesome. I love the idea of having the film take place in our universe rather than the universe of Ultraman. And this film does a great job at showing a monster attack from a human perspective (a trait that many monster films have forgotten about as of late). The sequences with older footage in them were all awesome as well. They made me want to see more Ultraseven in particular.
And Yuriko Hishimi is sooo hot, even though she's well into her 60s.
Also, to throw my two cents in about the stand-alone properties of this and UM&UB, this film stands alone perfectly well. It's okay to watch this film without having seen the previous film, but I wouldn't show it to someone that way. I'm not so worried about the flashbacks as much as I am the second half of this movie.
The second half is horrible. Firstly, there wasn't really an enemy for these characters to be fighting. Kaiju appeared for seemingly no reason other than having something to do with Mr. Purple Darth Sidious. And when it was revealed what the heck was actually happening, it was too shallow to even count. There was no explanation of WHY anything in the film was happening and the attempted explanation was a cop-out with no real information.
The ending itself is so incredibly bizarre that I can't take it seriously, and it lost its element of fun about 20 minutes before the ending even happens. This film had LOTR syndrome in that it simply wouldn't end even after the story was over. And the characters weren't deep enough for the movie to pull it off. The film was so caught up in being an homage that it forgot about being a film. I don't know what the actual last scene had to do with the rest of the plot at all, but I can only assume that it references something from one of the characters' respective tv shows? Maybe? No clue. Either way, the 57 endings of this movie ruined it for me.
I'm going to turn into my multi-armed form and yell at your general direction.