When the Enterprise was re-designed for the transition to the big screen in '79, it stirred the same mixed reaction.
I was at a con (Shuttlecon Columbus) in '78, and Roddenberry's production assistant Susan Sackett was there with Jimmy Doohan and Grace Lee Whitney. They had a panel where they unveiled -- not for the first time, but remember, there was no innertubes! -- the new 1701 for TMP. It was a slideshow, and she showed pictures of the bridge, the new uniforms, "the new captain" Decker (Stephen Collins), and ended it with the painting of Andy Probert's Enterprise. ("AUGGH!! FLAT NACELLES!!!"). I can't remember if that was the first time I'd seen it, or if it had already been in Starlog. I loved it from the get-go.
But there was lots of grumbling after that panel, with a year left until the release of the film. I don't recall it being
nearly as loud as some have been about Abram's Trek and this new Enterprise... but it wasn't quiet, gleeful and certainly not universal acceptance either.
Loved it then, love it now. The more I look at this new version, the more comfortable I get with it. This is interesting as well:
http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=73529 . Some guy who's done a decent job reconstructing a primitive model of it in 3D, so you can see it at different angles.
EDIT: 2:38am - Just saw Quantum of Solace and the Trailer. wow. WOW. Breathtaking. So rapid fire. The word is “GRANDâ€