by The Shadow » Mon Jan 05, 2015 3:59 am
With the first movie JJ, Orci, & Kurtzman were publicly committed about not going the alternate universe/reboot route until they finally had to fess up. If Paramount et al. had been upfront about rebooting Star Trek I think Nu-Trek's reception would have gone over better.
Of course, that still leaves Nu Trek's fundamental flaw, the Romulan Empire's core sun going supernova. The Nero gets thrown back over a century in the past and instead of making a bee line for Romulus & Remus to inform the Romulan Empire what's up, he goes on a revenge quest against the Federation, and more specifically Spock because his family died when the RE's core planets were destroyed.
And of course, the Nu-Trek universe also requires that Federation, Romulan, Klingon, etc. astrophysicists are utterly incapable of detecting that a star is destabilizing and going to go supernova until pretty much the last moment. Further the Romulan Empire seemingly could not even effect an evacuation of the populations of Romulus and Remus -- this is Star Trek, we know that at least the Federation would have been sending all sorts of ships to help with an evacuation.
Who knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men?