by jellydonut25 » Tue Jun 02, 2015 1:54 pm
I really think it's only racist to change the race of characters whose races are in some way inherent to their background. The Captain America example was a good one. Who in the 1940s would select a black soldier to be given superpowers? Superman is probably a good one too, honestly. Small rural Kansas town is gonna be accepting of a pair of farmers who claim a little black baby is theirs?
But why can't we believe that a high school kid from a lower-middle-class family who never knew his parents is a black kid? Because 50 years ago, he was drawn white because there's NO WAY a main hero character created in the early 60s would have been a black character when comics were still putting their black characters into books called Jungle Comics and All-Negro Comics?
Is it pandering to change the race of Spider-Man? I'd argue the only way it IS is if you do it and then make Spider-Man a lower-tier hero who has fewer books, and never participates in major storylines. Then it's that old "Look. We have a black hero, see!?!? Never you mind that he doesn't do anything of importance whatsoever."