by canofhumdingers » Sun Oct 01, 2017 10:18 pm
Batman Begins - Man, every time I watch this film I love it more. This might be the best Batman film ever made. Sometimes I even think it might eclipse the '89 film as my personal favorite, but when I sit down and honestly compare them, '89 always comes out ahead for me. Still, this is a great film. They NAIL all the quintessential things that make Batman Batman. While I favor the production design from '89, I greatly appreciate the careful thought that clearly went into every element here. The Tumbler is a beast of a machine. The batsuit is beautiful and intimidating. I also enjoy how this trilogy is probably the closest we'll ever get to seeing what Batman would be like in the real world (though I'd challenge anyone who claims Nolan's bat-universe is truly "realistic"). The story is superb and gracefully rises above being "yet another origin story" for something any fan has seen the origin of countless times over various media. The casting is solid. Most of the tertiary characters are great. Bale turns in a quality performance, though I think the writing is stronger than his acting. Liam Neeson is wonderful (is he ever anything less than top notch? Even in crappy movies he's awesome). I'm glad they recast Rachel in the sequel, but whatsherface is good enough in the role here (not great, but good enough). Overall an A++ Batfilm. It kills me that I never saw this in the theater. I graduated college just a month before this came out and was so busy that I never even heard of it until it was done theatrically. Hopefully I'll be able to remedy that at a (35mm please please?) revival screening sometime in the future.
The Dark Knight - What can I say that hasn't been said already? An amazing work that broke all the boundaries and records of super hero films. Ledger's Joker will be remembered as one of the greatest film villains every committed to celluloid. Up there with Darth Vader and Hannibal Lector. That performance has surpassed fame to become legendary, an I think it would have done so even without his untimely death. That being said, this film is definitely more about the villains than the hero. But even so, Batman still gets a very satisfying arc with solid character development. And that ending montage narration... man, it is no exaggeration to say it still gives me goosebumps every time. SO good! Regarding the batsuit, I love the idea behind the redesign, but I don't love the actual new design. I don't hate it, but it's certainly low on my list of favorite live action batsuits. The batpod is another cool idea that is well executed, although it really doesn't make any sense whatsoever for it to be part of the tumbler's design based on the tumbler's in-universe origin. Overall an absolutely amazing sequel. While I don't agree, I can totally understand why anyone might claim this surpasses Batman Begins.
The Dark Knight Rises - A solid ending to an amazing trilogy. This trilogy kinda reminds me of the original Star Wars trilogy: a brilliant start, an incredible sequel that has reasonable claim to being even better than the first, and a solid finale that fails to live up to the previous entries but still delivers a satisfying conclusion (although I'd say TDKR is over all higher quality than ROTJ, even though I love ROTJ). Bane is a really neat new take on the character. They waded into dangerous waters straying so far from his source material, but this is a rare instance where I think they fully succeeded. I know many complained about his voice, but I liked it and never found it unintelligible. Catwoman was well done and a pretty faithful representation. I do wish her costume had been a little more on-the-nose with the cat theme, but even as it was it fit well into the world they had built. I'm not overly crazy about the atomic bomb plot, but it's serviceable. It's funny, Talia had me totally fooled the first time I saw this movie, but on subsequent viewings her foreshadowing it SO BLATANTLY obvious. She literally quotes her father more than once! Bruce Wayne's story (and this film is very much a Bruce Wayne story over a Batman story) is really gratifying. He succeeds in making Batman truly a symbol and legend and is rewarded with the ability to retire into anonymity. It wouldn't work for all incarnations of Batman, but in this trilogy, seeing him make it to the point where he no longer needs Batman and can gladly relinquish the cowl to the next in line (Robin Jonathan Blake - in another well orchestrated turn of events) is just the perfect ending. And to those who say he didn't really survive: PHOOEY! It's clearly the film's intent that he does. All the way back to Batman Begins he was wistfully talking about a time when he wouldn't need to be Batman (even if he didn't completely mean it yet). In the final montage it's mentioned that Bruce Wayne fixed the autopilot 6 months ago, and when cataloging the remainder of the Wayne estate they say everything is accounted for except a string of pearls, which Selina happens to be wearing at the cafe. Also, while it's a bit of a stretch, it is possible that he could have flown the bomb far enough out to eject unseen and still had the autopilot fly far enough from him to survive the blast. It's said the bomb has a 6 mile blast radius. Back when the film came out, I actually crunched the numbers and it could work. It's not probable, but it is possible. And... he's Batman.