by Gabbara Davis, Jr. » Sun Jul 20, 2008 10:36 am
Toho has always been litigious when it comes to protecting the Godzilla trademark. Back in the 1980's I was working with the largest NY comic con organizer (Great Eastern) to bring the first official, Toho-sanctioned convention to the US. We were negotiating with both Toho and Saperstein. At the time I took a lot of flack from folks because my approach was to NEGOTIATE with Toho, rather than just hold conventions without their permission. Knowing Toho's tendency to sue, rather than negotiate, everyone was either terrified of them, or confrontational. I am sure a lot of you remember that era, when "Toho" was seen as a bad word.
I still have the hand written note written to me by J. D. Lees telling me a convention was impossible, and how he didn't think there was a market for one anyway. (Later, of course, Lees went on to launch G-Con. Whether Lees was trying to stifle competing cons, or he really had a quick change of heart, will never be known for sure. In any event, Great Eastern went under, G-Con was a success, and the fandom came out better for it.)
I remember talking to a few folks in Toho and the US fandom, and at the time Toho was threatening anything with a "ZILLA" on the end of it. They were also losing those suits, but for fans it sent a chilling message.This was also around the same time that Warner Bros. was suing fans for having Batman fan websites, or writing Batman related fan fiction.
To some degree, this trademark lunacy has calmed down. But Toho has a long tradition of being very, very, very protective of its mark.